Why the Shampoo That Works for Your Friend Doesn’t Work for You

November 15, 2026 · April Mullen

I hear some version of this every week: “My friend swears by this shampoo, so I bought it, and my hair hates it.” Of course it does. Your friend’s hair isn’t your hair. The product that’s perfect for her can be exactly wrong for you, and that’s not the product’s fault.

Hair isn’t one thing

When I recommend something, I’m not thinking about what’s popular. I’m thinking about four things: how fine or coarse your hair is, whether it’s color-treated, whether it runs dry, and whether it frizzes. Change any one of those and the right product changes with it.

Fine hair gets weighed down fast. The rich, creamy conditioner your friend with thick hair loves will leave fine hair flat and greasy by lunch. Fine hair usually wants something lighter, and conditioner on the ends, not the roots.

Coarse hair is the opposite. It drinks up moisture and still wants more. A light product barely registers on it.

Color-treated hair needs gentle cleansing. A harsh clarifying shampoo will strip color faster than anything else you do at home, and then everybody wonders why their color faded in three weeks. This is the one I’m most particular about, because you paid for that color and I want it to last.

Dry and frizzy aren’t the same problem. I keep saying this because it matters. Dry is moisture, and the right shampoo, conditioner and a conditioning treatment fix it. Frizz is texture. If your hair frizzes no matter how much conditioner you use, more moisture won’t settle it. That’s what my Smoothing System is for.

Grey changes the rules

As hair goes grey, it changes texture too. It comes in coarser and wirier, and your scalp makes less of the oil that used to keep it soft. So the products that worked for you at forty may not be right anymore. That’s not you doing anything wrong. Your hair changed, and your routine is allowed to change with it.

Why I use Redken

I use Redken in my chair and I sell it in my studio because I trust it, and because the line is broad enough that I can match it to the hair actually sitting in front of me. Moisture for dry hair, gentler cleansing for color, lighter styling products for fine hair, more hold for hair that won’t stay put. I’m not going to hand you the whole shelf. I’d rather hand you the two things your hair needs.

The drugstore isn’t the enemy

I’m not going to tell you everything outside a salon is bad. Plenty of people do fine with what they pick up at the store. My point is simpler: the best product is the one matched to your hair, and the easiest way to get that match is to ask the person who has her hands in your hair every six weeks.

Buying it as a gift? Ask first

This time of year I get a lot of people trying to buy hair products as presents. Here’s my advice: don’t guess. If the person you’re shopping for is one of my clients, call or text me at (540) 877-4057. I know her hair, I know what she’s using, and I’ll tell you what she’d actually love. You stop by and pick it up. No wasted bottles under the sink.

And if you’re not sure what your own hair needs, ask me at your next appointment, or start with a free consultation. I’m right here in Gainesboro, an easy drive from Winchester, Lake Holiday and Stephens City. Book here any time.

Because Trust Matters

Book an Appointment

Ready when you are.

One chair, one client at a time, on a quiet road in Gainesboro. Booking is open day or night.

Book Now
Book an Appointment